On the anniversary of his beloved wife Hannah's death, Dr. Michael Everett receives a letter from her. In it she reminds him of her love and makes one final, seemingly impossible request. "I want you to marry again." To that end, she asks him to consider three women.
First on Hannah's list is her cousin, Winter Adams, a trained chef who owns Blossom Street's French Café. The second is Leanne Lancaster, Hannah's oncology nurse. Michael knows them both. But the third name is one he's not familiar with Macy Roth.
Each woman has her own heartache, her own private grief. More than a year earlier, Winter broke off her relationship with another chef. Leanne is divorced from a man who defrauded the hospital for which she works. And Macy lacks family of her own, the family she craves.
During the months that follow, Michael spends time with Winter, Leanne and Macy, learning more about each of them and more about himself. Learning what Hannah already knew. That he's a man who needs the completeness only love can offer. And Hannah's list leads him to the woman who can help him find it.